On the article – a translated version as written by an opinion leader in China’s Bitcoin community, Huang Shiliang – portraying the deployment of SegWit as equal to the deployment of Lightning, Decker says the claim is not true for a reason: SegWit includes a number of fixes that are unrelated to Lightning and opens the possibility of new features, improves the security of the Bitcoin network and help create some headroom for a higher transaction rate.
Despite admitting that Lightning can potentially be built on top of various blockchains, Decker maintains that all the Lightning implementations are currently concentrating on Bitcoin.
“Lightning is a new tool in our toolbox, why would you retire a hammer, just because you got a new screwdriver?”
In October, Blockstream announced it sent the first end-to-end transaction over the Lightning Network to another party through a process that included invoicing a party for Bitcoin and routing the payment through multiple nodes. The test also showed that Lightning moved from the concept to the implementation stage.
Some of the points made about the Lightning Network in a recent article published on 8btc “builds on a number of very common misconceptions about Lightning” says one of the developers with Montreal-based Blockstream which runs the protocol.
“On the other hand, Lightning does not need SegWit strictly speaking, the needed changes to the Bitcoin protocol can be implemented in a number of ways. The article attempts to dissuade people from adopting SegWit in order to delay the deployment of Lightning, but not deploying SegWit would only result in a weaker Bitcoin network now, and slightly delay Lightning, potentially giving other blockchains an advantage, because they can deploy Lightning. “So I can confidently say that not deploying SegWit for the sake of delaying Lightning is a mistake. In fact there is no reason to delay Lightning in the first place, it is a complementary technology to the main Bitcoin network, and furthers Bitcoin’s reach into a number of use-cases that were so far unreachable.”
Christian Decker in an email highlights some of these misconceptions as including the assumption that Lightning will eventually replace classical Bitcoin transactions completely, making Bitcoin itself obsolete; that it interprets the fact that it can potentially be built on top of other blockchains is detrimental to Bitcoin itself; and that it equates SegWit with activation of Lightning.
While addressing each of the points individually, especially the parts of the article that described Lightning as a payment network that overrides Bitcoin network, Decker says: “Lightning relies heavily on Bitcoin as the base layer that is used to set up channels and settle them after we made a number of updates. We need the strong guarantees that Bitcoin provides us with, namely the double-spend protection, the fungibility of bitcoins and the finality of transactions in the blockchain. Without them it would not be possible to create a Lightning channel, and coins on the channel would be without value. Lightning will not replace Bitcoin, and users will always have the option to transact directly on the blockchain.”
There are however use-cases for which Bitcoin is not fit, he explains further. They include small transactions, with low fees, that have to be confirmed in a matter of seconds. It is for these use-cases that Lightning is being created as a complementary technology that expands the reach of Bitcoin.
“We are deeply committed to the Bitcoin ecosystem, and are heavily invested in the future of Bitcoin. Yes, Lightning can be used as a layer to transfer between various blockchains, however this happens through intermediaries, such as exchanges, on the boundaries of the network, which provide an exchange service between the base currencies. Any coins denominated in a currency are always bound to the corresponding blockchain, so bitcoins never leave the Bitcoin blockchain.”
Purse Launches Testnet for Bitcoin Scaling Tech 'Extension Blocks'
A new element was added to the bitcoin scaling debate this week when the developer team behind startup Purse announced the launch of a testnet to trial its scaling solution, extension blocks.
Charlie Shrem: Hold At Least 10 Bitcoins, Can Buy House in 30 Years
A couple of weeks ago Bitcoin legend Charlie Shrem hosted a BlockShow Europe 2017 which was organized by Cointelegraph Events in partnership with Deloitte Germany, nexussquared and BlockPay. The
SWIFT to Use Hyperledger for Joint Blockchain Payments Project
The global payment relay network SWIFT has announced it will use Hyperledger as a basis for simplifying international transactions. In a trial together with Australia and New Zealand Banking Group,
Breaking: SEC Will Review Decision of Winklevoss Bitcoin ETF Rejection
The securities and exchange commission has granted a request by the Bats BZX Exchange, Inc. to review its decision of disapproving the bitcoin ETF back in March this year. According to a document sign
California Dusts off Virtual Currency Act à la NY’s BitLicense
California has dusted off its notion of a ‘Virtual Currency Act.’ A new bill seeks to prohibit a person from engaging in any virtual currency business sans license from the Commissioner of Business Ov
The SEC is Now Weighing an Ethereum ETF Proposal
The SEC has quietly begun the process of weighing whether to approve an exchange-traded fund (ETF) for the cryptocurrency ether (ETH).
The backers of the EtherIndex Ether Trust first filed in July
SEC Orders Review of Winklevoss Bitcoin ETF Rejection
The SEC intends to review its decision to reject a bitcoin exchange-traded fund proposed by investors Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss.
As previously reported by CoinDesk, the SEC shot down a bid by th
South Korea is Ready to Test Blockchain, Selects Insurance Company For Pilot Experiments
Kyobo Life, one of the largest insurance providers in the country, was selected by the South Korean government as the major operator of its Blockchain project. Kyobo is expected to facilitate tests