“How can it be the case that the IRS is unable to estimate the extent of any virtual currency tax noncompliance, yet it told this court that tax evasion using virtual currency was so serious that it justified the government obtaining personal and financial data concerning millions of taxpayers merely because they had engaged in a transaction involving virtual currency?”
The fact that virtual currency is a new technology should not change the legal case, the motion noted. If three taxpayers used Bank of America wire transfers in tax avoidance schemes, then petitioned the court to serve a summons to identify every bank customer who used a bank transfer and produce all documents on those customers, the outrage would be “limitless,” the motion noted.
Jeffrey Berns, an attorney representing Coinbase in its legal fight against the Internal Revenue Service summons to provide customer information, recently filed a response to the “John Doe” summons, asking the court to quash the summons in its entirety, order a limited hearing and discovery into government’s good faith, or reconsider its decision to grant the IRS petition.
The motion noted that a Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA Report), which was issued two months before the IRS filed its petition, criticized the IRS for not having the ability to analyze the risk of virtual currency tax noncompliance and estimate its significance.
The report then offered multiple recommendations for the IRS to fix the problem, such as clarifying its vague virtual currency taxation policies to increase voluntary taxpayer compliance.
Berns argued the summons statute does not permit the government to protect itself from inquiries on its acting in good faith.
The reply disputed the government’s claim that Berns’ motion is moot because on Dec. 27, 2016, the IRS withdrew the summons as it applied to Berns only, even though it had not obtained any of the documents or information sought by the summons with respect to Berns. Berns contended that the court should reject the government’s attempt to artificially moot the motion because it does not want the court to scrutinize its actions in pursuing the improper summons.
Berns, in his motion, said the court can conclude the government acted in bad faith in pursuing the IRS summons or that additional inquiry into its motives is needed. Berns is the managing partner of Berns Weiss LLP and is also a Coinbase customer.
While it contends that it is “pure speculation” that the IRS is seeking the summons for research purposes, evidence indicates the IRS does not have the ability to examine the tax returns of many Coinbase customers for tax compliance, Berns’ motion noted.
Also read: DOJ lawyers argue Coinbase customers can’t challenge the IRS’s summons
On December 1, a federal judge approved the IRS summons and demanded Coinbase reveal user transaction records.
Berns’ motion calls the IRS summons “unprecedented use” of the IRS John Doe summons procedure.
Berns said he is ready to withdraw his initial motion if the court reconsiders its initial ruling. He said he is trying to protect the rights of Coinbase customers from the bad faith the government is showing in exercising the right to serve the summons. He said an additional inquiry is needed into the government’s motives.
To avoid scrutiny of its motives, the agency has acknowledged it does not need all the information it is seeking, the motion stated. It said the IRS acted in bad faith in issuing a summons for information it does not need.
Images from Shutterstock.
Berns’ motion claimed that based on three instances of taxpayers using bitcoin to avoid paying undisclosed amounts of income taxes, the agency is using the John Doe summons process to require Coinbase to identify millions of its U.S. customers and to provide “substantial personal and financial information concerning those customers, some of which has absolutely no relation to any tax compliance issue.”
Berns filed his recent motion in response to the IRS’s reply to his motion to intervene and quash the John Doe summons.
In response to his report, the IRS ignores most of the recommendations, the motion claimed.
Berns claimed the court should reconsider allowing the IRS to issue the summons considering there are questions about the agency’s motives for gathering information. He argued there is no basis for the agency or anyone to conclude it is likely Coinbase customers engage in tax avoidance activity just because they do business with virtual currency.
Coinbase has said it is committed to customer privacy and opposes the government’s efforts to gain customer information. Coinbase does not have to take any action unless and until the government begins a proceeding to enforce the summons.
Bitcoin Rebounds From Two-Month Low to Top $1,000
After falling to their lowest level in more than two months this weekend, bitcoin prices breached $1,000 again today.
Overall, the digital currency rose as much as 7.5% during the session, clim
SAP Joins HyperLedger, as Enterprise Blockchain Wave Sweeps In
The increasing adoption of distributed ledger technology by companies has made it hard for the enterprise solutions providers to ignore the blockchain. In order to keep up with the changing times,
Bitcoin Price Stabilizes at $1,022, Scalability Debate Continues
Bitcoin price reached $1,030 in most global Bitcoin exchanges such as Bitstamp and Bitfinex earlier today, recovering from the March 24 drop which occurred due to speculations on the likelihood of
Newsflash: Bitcoin Rises, US Dollar Sinks
Bitcoin prices have bounced back above $1,000 on Monday, registering a high of $1,032 on the Bitstamp Price Index.
Bitcoin is trading near the levels of the week past, finding its feet after a drop
Is Bitcoin A Safe Way To Transact Money?
Let me first say that I’m speaking as myself and not on behalf of the Federal Reserve System. Also, that my expertise is in the world of physical cash, so I’m not an expert in bitcoin.
Jeff Garzik’s Bloq Launches BloqLabs to Expand Support for Blockchain, Bitcoin Projects
Bloq, a provider of blockchain solutions, has launched BloqLabs to expand its support of open source blockchain and bitcoin projects, the company announced on its website.
“In the 1900s, Bell Labs
BitOasis Expands Credit Card Bitcoin Buying to 5 New Countries
BitOasis has announced it will expand a credit card buying option to additional countries in the Middle East.
In a move that follows its unveiling of an 'instant buy' option for UAE customers this
Bitfury Mines a Block Signalling User-Activated SegWit Soft Fork
Bitfury is reported is to have mined a block supporting the BIP 148 proposal, effectively signalling a user-activated softfork (UASF) for SegWit.
As the debate surrounding bitcoin’s block size cont