This collision of Dimon, Law, and bitcoin was created by Joel Dietz with his piece in the November Bitcoin magazine entitled, “Why John Law Gambles with Bitcoins.” Dietz, 300 years after the fact, presents a thought experiment with the question, “What would [Law] say about Bitcoin and other digital currencies.”
Diest gives the impression that Law started what would become the Mississippi Company to raise money to settle the Louisiana Purchase and bring “back the great riches of the new world.
Technology and private enterprise have arrived just in time to compete with government in the monetary arena. The last thing needed is a currency crank with friends in government to derail the prosperity private money can bring.
Law was the sole person who decided how much money Banque Generale would create. He did not want to be hemmed in by limits to his money issuance. He believed his system was saving France, its government, and creating prosperity. While its possible Law learned something from the debacle he created, assuming he’d embrace the strictures of Satochi’s structure is far-fetched.
Joe Salerno weighs in on Law’s legacy in his book Money: Sound and Unsound.
Dietz is more likely to be right that Law “would almost certainly be running the circuit talking to central bankers.” Law believed as central bankers believe today, that economies can be managed if the right smart people are in charge, what Jim Grant calls the PHD standard. But competing crypto-currencies are the antithesis of central planning in money.
Evidently Dimon hasn’t heard only 21 million bitcoin can be produced and it gets harder and harder to create new bitcoin, with only a few produced each hour. We can’t say the same for the Federal Reserve and its partners in money creation, the commercial banks.
I’m not sure who Dietz thinks has been hailing Law for greatness. Charles Rist, in his book History of Money and Credit: From John Law to the Present Day, wrote of Law’s theories,
Jamie Dimon opened his mouth in Davos about bitcoin and nonsense came out. “It’s a terrible store of value,” Dimon told CNBC’s Andrew Ross Sorkin. “It could be replicated over and over.”
Only Keynesians have a soft spot in their hearts for Law. Law biographer and Mississippi Bubble expert Antoin Murphy said it best. “Keynes can be termed as post-Lawian!”
While Dietz gets many of the juicy anecdotes about the Scotsman correct, he starts spinning the Law legacy from his opening sentence, “Today, John Law is often hailed as one of the greatest financial innovators of all time.”
These facts fly in the face of Dietz’s comment, “Law’s primary flaw was that he was too successful.”
While Law’s system relieved the government’s debt service, the resulting inflation, in the words of economic historian Earl Hamilton, “was a catastrophe to the labouring class.” Overall, prices more than doubled for the working class and the prices of some food items (like bread) soared 300 to 400 percent.
Dietz takes a big leap when he writes, “It should be clear that Law would see digital money as the future.” The value of bitcoin and successful cryptocurrencies is in their limited number. Dimon may think bitcoin can be reproduced ad infinitum but Satochi put a lid on bitcoin issuance for a reason. His creation of the best known cybercurrency was a direct response to the mismanagement of money by central banks that endlessly create money. The result being distractive booms, busts and inflation.
as the founder and head of what, in effect, was one of the first national central banks in history, the Banque Generale (later, the Banque Royale) of France, Law almost singlehandedly destroyed the French monetary system in the course of four short years (1716-1720). As a monetary theorist, Law has been called the “ancestor of the idea of a managed currency” by no less an authority on economic doctrine than Joseph Schumpeter.
However, cryptocurrency is the future for the exact opposite reason. The vision needed is not Law’s but Hayek’s, who wrote, “It seems to me that if we could prevent governments from meddling with money, we would do more good than any government has done in this regard. And private enterprise would probably have done better than the best they have ever done.”
However, Law had a skeleton in his closet in the form of Edward Wilson, whom he killed in a duel for which details remain sketchy. (Did the two men duel over Elizabeth Villiers, “the king’s boss-eyed, unattractive mistress,” or a certain Mrs. Lawrence, or money Wilson had received from a homosexual lover?) Dimon’s skeletons are all in the open as JPMorgan pays various fines for the bank’s running afoul of the regulators.
The lack of government standing means there would be no bitcoin bailout for JP Morgan should the need arise. No wonder wonder Dimon hates it. As far as being used for illicit purposes, that’s rich coming from a guy whose bank was just fined two billion dollars for not alerting the authorities to the activities of one of their customers, Bernie Madoff.
While the company’s sole asset was government-granted trading rights with this new territory, the use of funds raised through stock sales was to refinance France’s burdensome debt.
An abundance of money which would lower the interest rate to 2% would, in reducing the financing costs of the debts and public offices etc. relieve the King. It would lighten the burden of the indebted noble landowners. This latter group would be enriched because agricultural goods would be sold at higher prices. It would enrich traders who would then be able to borrow at a lower interest rate and give employment to the people.
“Cryptocurrency is the future,” Dietz concludes. “It just calls for a bit of vision and boldness to pull it off on the scale needed. It needs another John Law.” What Dietz dreams of is Law sliding into the shoes of Janet Yellen or Mario Draghi and turning all government paper and coin into government digits.
Followers of the Fed and Keynesian policies will find this John Law quote familiar.
LORD KEYNES has always appeared to me as a new John Law. Like Law, Keynes was a financial genius who made some real contributions to the theory of money…But Keynes could never free himself from the popular false belief that, as Law expressed it, “as the additional money will give work to the people who were idled and enabled those already working to earn more, the output will increase and industry will proper.”
Law’s writings . . . already contain all the ideas which constitute the equipment of currency cranks—fluctuations in the value of the precious metals as an obstacle to their use as a standard . . . the ease with which they can be replaced by paper money, money defined simply as an instrument of circulation (its function of serving as a store of value being ignored), and the conclusion drawn from this definition that any object can be used for such an instrument, the hoarding of money as an offence on the part of the citizens, the right of the government to take legal action against such an offence, and to take charge of the money reserves of individuals as they do of the main roads, the costliness of the precious metals compared with the cheapness of paper money.
These days, Dimon is viewed as the smartest banker in any room he enters. In 1716 France John Law was that guy. Way more interesting than Dimon, Law was James Bond-like — a suave, debonair, womanizing gambler who (like Dimon) always seemed to come out on top. Law had plenty of friends in high places and worked the party circuit throughout Europe, as Dimon works Davos today.
In Choice in Currency F.A. Hayek linked Law and Keynes.
“It doesn’t have the standing of a government,” added Dimon. “And honestly, a lot of it — what I’ve read from you guys — a lot of it is being used for illicit purposes.”
Who's Said What About the Coinbase-Visa Payment Dispute
Users of cryptocurrency startup Coinbase have seen repeated charges appear on their bank statements tied to their Visa credit and debit card use in recent days, prompting several rounds of statements
Actor Steven Seagal Endorses Questionable 'Bitcoiin' ICO
Action film star Steven Seagal has become the brand ambassador for a controversial cryptocurrency ahead of an initial coin offering (ICO).
A statement posted to Seagal's Twitter account confirmed t
Israel Confirms It Will Tax Bitcoin as Property
Israel's government confirmed Monday that it would treat bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies as a kind of property for tax purposes.
The notice confirms past indications that the Tax Authority will
Who Said What About Coinbase and Visa's User Payment Dispute
Users of cryptocurrency startup Coinbase saw repeated charges appear on their bank statements tied to their Visa credit and debit card use, prompting several rounds of statements from the companies in
Banks Buy Stakes in Blockchain Startup SETL
Financial services group Citi has bought a stake in blockchain startup SETL.
The move, announced today, comes less than three weeks after the French banking institution Credit Agricole also became
Long Blockchain Is At Risk for Exchange Removal Again
Long Blockchain, the beverage company-turned-crypto-firm, is facing a delisting from the Nasdaq stock exchange, public records show.
The reason lies in Long Blockchain's sliding stock price, which
Bitcoin thieves threaten real violence for virtual currencies
The currency they were after was virtual, but the guns they carried were anything but. In the beach resort of Phuket, Thailand, last month, the assailants pushed their victim, a young Russian man,
Lithuania's Central Bank Probes 100 Million Euro ICO
Lithuania's central bank announced last week that it is probing a domestic initial coin offering (ICO) after determining that the token offered counts as a security.
In a Feb. 15 statement, the Lie