Although Bitcoin developers may not view altcoins as serious threats, Zcash CEO and longtime cypherpunk Zooko Wilcox-O’Hearn recently warned the Bitcoin community to not become too complacent in the push for Bitcoin.
Dilley went on to discuss the security concerns associated with altcoins. Critics often point to low network hashrates and alternative consensus models as potential risks of these alternatives to Bitcoin. Dilley added, “If you’re going to fall back to [a weaker security model], you might as well be piggybacking off Bitcoin via sidechains.”
Dilley went on to explain that there are definitely some members of the Bitcoin community who would seize on the opportunity to attack if they saw an opportunity to increase their return on an altcoin speculation. The head of strategy at Blockstream pointed to the large number of scams in the Bitcoin ecosystem over the past few years as a way to explain that there is no shortage of nefarious actors in the space.
Altcoins have a long tradition in the Bitcoin community, but they tend to cause a contentious divide among those who think they’re useful and those who think they’re all scams. One side of the argument, articulated by the Satoshi Nakamoto Institute’s Daniel Krawisz, is that altcoins have no chance of success and distract possible users from Bitcoin, while the other side, articulated by many Ethereum supporters, believe platforms such as Bitcoin and Ethereum can work together.
There has been some uncertainty in the Bitcoin market recently due to the ongoing scaling debate. Dilley was asked on The Crypto Show whether he thinks this uncertainty has led to some Bitcoin holders fleeing into altcoins. At first, Dilley responded, “I think there’s some serious, perverse incentives [for altcoin holders to cause uncertainty for Bitcoin], and that’s a broader topic.”
In terms of whether altcoins are a threat to Bitcoin, Dilley said:
The Vast Majority of Altcoins Are Scams
Bitcoin Developers Not Threatened by Altcoins
Does Uncertainty in Bitcoin Fuel Altcoins?
In the past, many altcoins have marketed themselves with some sort of comparative advantage to Bitcoin. For example, some altcoins have touted faster confirmation times; others claim to offer privacy enhancements. For the most part, Bitcoin developers have focused on implementing their own innovations rather than responding to what’s going on with the altcoin market.
When first asked about altcoins, Dilley echoed recent statements made by Monero developer Riccardo Spagni and stated, “I continue to believe that the vast majority of altcoins are scams. They provide no functionality whatsoever, or the functionality they could provide could very easily be implemented via a sidechain.”
“I don’t think the Bitcoin developers ‒ they’re not doing things from a perceived competitive perspective. Their perspective is: ‘I have this awesome piece of technology, and I want to be able to help develop it and bring it more into what I think is interesting to build on top of this.’ So no, I don’t think it’s from a perceived threat of any of the altcoins.”
In addition to altcoin promoters, Mastering Bitcoin author Andreas Antonopoulos has noted the likelihood of attacks from various government agencies. Online Bitcoin discussions have turned into schoolyard-esque yelling matches over the past year, but it’s unclear how much of the divisiveness in the community has been organic. There are plenty of incentives for a variety of different types of non-Bitcoin users to throw gasoline on the fire.
A sidechain is an alternative blockchain to Bitcoin that uses the same Bitcoin currency through a pegging mechanism. The idea is to allow developers to experiment with completely new blockchains without having to bootstrap a new currency network (altcoin). Bitcoin Hivemind and Rootstock are two examples of sidechains currently in development. Blockstream has handled the vast majority of the development work for sidechains up to this point.
Johnny Dilley, who runs strategy at Blockstream, was recently asked for his thoughts on altcoins during an interview on The Crypto Show. Dilley believes the vast majority of altcoins are scams, and he also thinks Bitcoin developers are not threatened by the existence of these alternative cryptocurrencies. The incentive for altcoin speculators to promote uncertainty in the Bitcoin community was also discussed.
Purse Launches Testnet for Bitcoin Scaling Tech 'Extension Blocks'
A new element was added to the bitcoin scaling debate this week when the developer team behind startup Purse announced the launch of a testnet to trial its scaling solution, extension blocks.
Charlie Shrem: Hold At Least 10 Bitcoins, Can Buy House in 30 Years
A couple of weeks ago Bitcoin legend Charlie Shrem hosted a BlockShow Europe 2017 which was organized by Cointelegraph Events in partnership with Deloitte Germany, nexussquared and BlockPay. The
SWIFT to Use Hyperledger for Joint Blockchain Payments Project
The global payment relay network SWIFT has announced it will use Hyperledger as a basis for simplifying international transactions. In a trial together with Australia and New Zealand Banking Group,
Breaking: SEC Will Review Decision of Winklevoss Bitcoin ETF Rejection
The securities and exchange commission has granted a request by the Bats BZX Exchange, Inc. to review its decision of disapproving the bitcoin ETF back in March this year. According to a document sign
California Dusts off Virtual Currency Act à la NY’s BitLicense
California has dusted off its notion of a ‘Virtual Currency Act.’ A new bill seeks to prohibit a person from engaging in any virtual currency business sans license from the Commissioner of Business Ov
The SEC is Now Weighing an Ethereum ETF Proposal
The SEC has quietly begun the process of weighing whether to approve an exchange-traded fund (ETF) for the cryptocurrency ether (ETH).
The backers of the EtherIndex Ether Trust first filed in July
SEC Orders Review of Winklevoss Bitcoin ETF Rejection
The SEC intends to review its decision to reject a bitcoin exchange-traded fund proposed by investors Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss.
As previously reported by CoinDesk, the SEC shot down a bid by th
South Korea is Ready to Test Blockchain, Selects Insurance Company For Pilot Experiments
Kyobo Life, one of the largest insurance providers in the country, was selected by the South Korean government as the major operator of its Blockchain project. Kyobo is expected to facilitate tests