For example, those backing the petition assert that the CFTC's ruling suggest Bitfinex ran into trouble by holding the private keys associated with bitcoins loaned to traders, an action the CFTC interpreted as meaning the bitcoins in question were never actually delivered.
"Absent a definitive Commission statement identifying the essential elements, participants must attempt to discern what is lawful and what is problematic through assessments of enforcement orders, which are focused on a single entity at a time and may or may not be instructive."
To better understand and address such concerns, the letter requests that the CFTC undertake a rulemaking process that would find it soliciting feedback from the wider community on how it could best determine a more formal definition.
First appearing in the conversation around New York’s state-specific licensing regime, the BitLicense, technology advocacy groups have begun to more actively lobby for definitions that they believe better fit the technology's design in recent years.
US law firm Steptoe & Johnson LLP has filed a petition with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), calling on the agency to provide more clarity regarding the definition of "delivery" in blockchain-based transactions.
While Bitfinex was fined, it also settled its charges with the CFTC. However, the petition takes issue with the fact that the exact changes Bitfinex implemented to come into compliance were not made public, and that as such, any clarity as to how it satisfied the CFTC’s definition of delivery was never disseminated to the wider market.
'Know the answers' visualization via Shutterstock
Such wording, the petition contends, could lead to interpretations that custody and wallet control need to be directly linked in blockchain environments. Further, when combined with the long settlement times on public blockchains, these observers say, this might make certain business models based on prompt delivery more difficult to execute.
The petition goes on to argue that the definition of custody in a blockchain environment remains a gray area, one the authors assert is "harmful" to digital currency and blockchain startups.
Signed by Steptoe partner Micah Green and senior policy advisor (and former CFTC commissioner) Michael Dunn, the petition centers around actions the agency took against Hong Kong-based bitcoin exchange Bitfinex in June. At the time, the company paid $75,000 amid allegations that it never properly delivered certain funds to traders.
More broadly, the filing again raises questions regarding definitions of custody that have long been cited as an issue with existing US state laws meant to cover blockchain-based digital currencies.
Cftc Petition by CoinDesk on Scribd
Green and Dunn wrote:
"Given the novelty of both the cryptocurrency market and the use of blockchain technology, engaging the public through a notice-and-comment rulemaking process would help to inform the Commission about the relevant considerations in developing the elements of ‘actual delivery’ and the potential unintended consequences in rendering such an articulation," the notice reads.
Report Finds Cryptojacking Instances Jumped 400% In A Year
Instances of cryptojacking malware have jumped more than 400 percent since last year, a new report finds.
A collaborative group of cybersecurity researchers called the Cyber Threat Alliance (CTA) p
Bitmain CEO Announces New 7nm Bitcoin Mining Chip
The bitcoin mining industry is having an exciting couple of days.
Just a day after Bitfury revealed a new 14nm mining chip called the Bitfury Clarke, Bitmain has upped the ante with the announcemen
Brave Browser Is Using Civic's Blockchain Platform to Verify Publishers
Privacy-focused internet browser Brave will begin using blockchain identity startup Civic's verification services to ensure publishers are paid for their content with Brave's Basic Attention Token (BA
US Navy Launches Blockchain Research in Mission to Improve Tracking System
A U.S. Navy command is exploring the potential of blockchain technology in tracking aircraft parts.
The Naval Air Systems Command (NAVAIR) – which provides material support for aircraft and airborn
Reports: Taiwan Police Arrest Cody Wilson Following Assault Charges
Taiwan police have arrested Cody Wilson just days after Austin police accused him of sexually assaulting a minor, CBS Austin reported Friday.
Citing the Taiwan Criminal Investigation Bureau (CIB),
Tether's Impact on Bitcoin Price Not 'Statistically Significant,' Study Finds
The issuance of tether (USDT), the controversial cryptocurrency tied to the U.S. dollar's value, has had no meaningful impact on the price of bitcoin, an academic study has found.
The findings by D
Venezuela to Adopt Controversial Petro Token in Global Trade
Venezuela's President Nicolas Maduro is doubling down on his belief that the state-created petro token will help solve the country's chronic inflation and act to stabilize the economy.
During a TV
California Bans Bitcoin Donations in Political Campaigns
Candidates running for public offices in the U.S. state of California may not receive donations in cryptocurrencies, according to a new ruling from the state's political watchdog.
The Associated Pr