For example, those backing the petition assert that the CFTC's ruling suggest Bitfinex ran into trouble by holding the private keys associated with bitcoins loaned to traders, an action the CFTC interpreted as meaning the bitcoins in question were never actually delivered.
"Absent a definitive Commission statement identifying the essential elements, participants must attempt to discern what is lawful and what is problematic through assessments of enforcement orders, which are focused on a single entity at a time and may or may not be instructive."
To better understand and address such concerns, the letter requests that the CFTC undertake a rulemaking process that would find it soliciting feedback from the wider community on how it could best determine a more formal definition.
First appearing in the conversation around New York’s state-specific licensing regime, the BitLicense, technology advocacy groups have begun to more actively lobby for definitions that they believe better fit the technology's design in recent years.
US law firm Steptoe & Johnson LLP has filed a petition with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), calling on the agency to provide more clarity regarding the definition of "delivery" in blockchain-based transactions.
While Bitfinex was fined, it also settled its charges with the CFTC. However, the petition takes issue with the fact that the exact changes Bitfinex implemented to come into compliance were not made public, and that as such, any clarity as to how it satisfied the CFTC’s definition of delivery was never disseminated to the wider market.
'Know the answers' visualization via Shutterstock
Such wording, the petition contends, could lead to interpretations that custody and wallet control need to be directly linked in blockchain environments. Further, when combined with the long settlement times on public blockchains, these observers say, this might make certain business models based on prompt delivery more difficult to execute.
The petition goes on to argue that the definition of custody in a blockchain environment remains a gray area, one the authors assert is "harmful" to digital currency and blockchain startups.
Signed by Steptoe partner Micah Green and senior policy advisor (and former CFTC commissioner) Michael Dunn, the petition centers around actions the agency took against Hong Kong-based bitcoin exchange Bitfinex in June. At the time, the company paid $75,000 amid allegations that it never properly delivered certain funds to traders.
More broadly, the filing again raises questions regarding definitions of custody that have long been cited as an issue with existing US state laws meant to cover blockchain-based digital currencies.
Cftc Petition by CoinDesk on Scribd
Green and Dunn wrote:
"Given the novelty of both the cryptocurrency market and the use of blockchain technology, engaging the public through a notice-and-comment rulemaking process would help to inform the Commission about the relevant considerations in developing the elements of ‘actual delivery’ and the potential unintended consequences in rendering such an articulation," the notice reads.
G20 Eyes October Deadline for Crypto Anti-Money Laundering Standard
G20 member countries are now looking at an October deadline for reviewing a global anti-money laundering (AML) standard on cryptocurrency, document shows.
According to a statement issued on Sunday,
300 Million User Data from Chinese Delivery Giant Sold For 2 Bitcoins On Dark Web
It is revealed that 300 million pieces of user data from China’s second largest courier SF Express (Chinese version of UPS) were compromised and priced at 2 bitcoins on the dark web.
A post on th
Crypto Exchange Coinbase Forms Political Action Committee
Cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase has formed a Political Action Committee (PAC), according to government documents published Friday night.
A disclosure published by the U.S. Federal Election Commiss
Malta Says Crypto Rules Aren't Yet In Force
Malta's new cryptocurrency regulatory framework has not taken effect just yet.
Three bills regarding cryptocurrencies, blockchain and distributed ledger technology, passed by Maltese Members of Par
Huobi Launches Service to Build Crypto Exchanges in the Cloud
Huobi, the world's third-largest cryptocurrency exchange platform by trade volume, is now offering a business arm to help customers build their own digital asset exchanges.
Dubbed the Huobi Cloud,
CoinMarketCap Announces Changes to Counter Fake Volume Concerns
The popular crypto data tracker CoinMarketCap is instituting changes in light of what it called "concerns" over fake volume figures.
In a blog post, published on July 19, the site said that it had
You Can't Ban Math: Crypto Unites to Call Out Congressman
In the span of a few hours, it became Crypto Twitter vs U.S. Representative Brad Sherman.
On Wednesday, Congress hosted a pair of back-to-back hearings on the topic of cryptocurrencies (read CoinD
TSMC Says Crypto Mining Demand Will Fall in Q3
Semiconductor manufacturing giant TSMC said Thursday that it expects demand for cryptocurrency mining-related products to cool off during the third quarter of this year.
The company – which manufac