Miners were mining 50 coins every 10 minutes just over a year ago. With the geometric progression in the distribution of coins that happens every 4 years, the allocation is now 25 coins every 10 minutes. Less coins, albeit at a higher price. Even six months ago, miners were probably holding onto at least 50% of the coins they made and spending the other 50% on costs (electricity, salaries, hosting, hardware).
The real impact is that the notion that Bitcoin is a âdeflationaryâ currency vs the USD has effectively been dispelled. Any deflationary gains have to be offset via capital gains taxes. This does not mean that it is not deflationary vs other currencies, but given the IRS has given strong guidance hereâââitâs effectively mooted in the USA. It will remain a store of value, but it clearly is not a currency in itâs current form.
As the number of transactions via Bitcoin processors increase, it ultimately creates more sellers in the marketplaceâââwhich obviously creates downward pressure on the trading price. Now, Iâm not saying that this is a bad thing in the long term, but the problem is that if you have asymmetric growth in new Bitcoin users and Bitcoin âacceptorsâ, it will create a lopsided marketplace which will suppress the priceâââwhich is exactly what is currently happening. Weâre seeing the impact of this in the market right now, I believe. There is another factor, which brings me to my next point.
Iâd like to offer some alternative views:
History shows that it needs to find a very stable price point for a few months before it can really retest any previous highs. External factors like Russia, Ukraine, China, etc will contribute to Bitcoin volatility and changes in the supply/demand curve globally.
Whatâs now happening when new merchants start accepting Bitcoin is that itâs giving people who have existing coins the ability to use it as a currency and effectively âsellâ their coins to the merchant. The processors such as Bitpay (which Gyft uses to sellÂ gift cards) then in turn either sells these coins to private buyers (off book) or via exchanges (such as Bitstamp) to exchange for local currency for the merchants. This money is understandably used to continue to replenish inventory and operate their business, and more importantly, pay taxes to Uncle Sam.
So instead of âbuy sideâ money winding up in the exchanges which would be used to drive up the price, itâs sitting on the sidelines which has the impact of lowering the demand side of the equation within the marketplaces where Bitcoin is priced.
Disclosure: I own Bitcoins personally and within my company,Â Gyft, which accepts Bitcoin as a payment method. I have bought some Bitcoin today at the current price and will buy & sell them in the foreseeable future. I have every intention to keep trading Bitcoin. The information above is not to be misconstrued as investment advice. Bitcoin is a highly speculative commodity that is best traded by people who have a passion for and understanding of disruptive technologies. Please consult your financial advisor before taking any advice from someone who clearly has nothing better to do that write about Bitcoin on a Sunday evening.
Given the above, the Bitcoin price has been struggling and this creates downward momentum. The good news is that it keeps out the âget rich quickâ types (for now) who typically almost justify the reasoning of some of the non-believers who think that Bitcoin is a Ponzi scheme.
I also donât believe Bitcoin is suitable as currencyâââI think itâs a commodity that can be traded for goods and services. It may become a currency in time, but it just isnât one right now. Itâs a scarce, digital commodityâââand the trading that takes place on exchanges really reflects the market sentiment around the value of this digital commodity.
One of the leaders in the Bitcoin space, helping people spend their BTC at a wide range of traditional stores ranging from Target and Whole Foods Market, to the recent addition of Wal Mart is Gyft, led by its CEO Vinny Lingham. Iâve known for some time now how intelligent and entrepreneurial Vinny is, but as of today I have also discovered he is a strong writer.
The IRS guidance when coupled with unconfirmed rumours that China is âbanningâ Bitcoin has led the mainstream press to postulate that these are the reasons for the current weakness in the price.
Although many Bitcoiners are hoping for more large retailers like TigerDirect and Overstock to adopt Bitcoin, it may have a negative impact on the BTC price as these retailers will most likely convert 90% of their coins to cashâââputting additional selling pressure on Bitcoin. This outcome may not be as desirable in the short term, but it will create a better long-term outlook for Bitcoin given the liquidity options. Again, if you asymmetrically add large retailers without driving consumer adoption at the same time, the demand supply curve will shift undesirably.
If someone wanted to track the flow of coins via the pools and see how many of them wound up on the exchanges or spent at retail, I think the results would be fascinating (let know if you or someone you know has or wants to do this).
The US does not have a single licensed Bitcoin exchange and the rest of the world is reeling from MtGox. Bitstamp is proving to be the new global exchange of choice but the media has done a great job of keeping new potential Bitcoin users at bay with the usual inflammatory headlines whenever something negative happens in the Bitcoin space.
That said, conversely, here are the key reasons why I think the Bitcoin price may not organically reach $1,000 again this year, without an external event shifting the supply/demand curve for Bitcoin. It is difficult to predict anything further out than a single quarter in the Bitcoin world, so instead of making bold predictions I would rather focus on highlighting some issues that are suppressing the Bitcoin right now.
Bitcoin has a number of headwinds which is keeping the price in check. Iâm expecting it to stabilize around the $400 mark for at least the next quarter (although predictions in the Bitcoin space are very hard to do past a couple of weeks).
Bitcoin is currently trying to finding an equilibrium pointâââat least at the current volume levelsâââgiven all the recent disruptions to the ecosystem (including the recent MtGox collapse). Equilibrium would be defined for me as the point of stability in price where there is symetric volume and consistent growth on a daily basis between buyers and sellers (utopian, but right now there is asymmetric growth which is not being quantifiedâââso traders are having a problem predicting where it would go).
Most people I know who want to buy and sell Bitcoin are doing it âoff-bookââââwhich means the transactions are going instead via trusted networks. This will take buyers out of the marketplace and will ultimately mask the true supply/demand curve for Bitcoin. Anyone who doesnât know a buyer will sell their coins via an exchange or via a merchant accepting Bitcoin which will put sell side pressure on the BTC price.
Given the reasons above, I think that Bitcoin will be range-bound in the $350-$550 range for at least the next quarter, that is, unless an external catalytic event occurs. I do think weâll see a point of equilibrium & stability where the price stabilizes for a couple of monthsâââwhen you see that, it should be a sign that a future surge is in the cards (based on historical evidence).
With his permission I am republishing his excellent piece,Â Finding Equilibrium: Searching for the true value of a Bitcoin, below.
That number is now probably closer to 80% and dropping (lower margins at lower BTC prices and lower efficiency of mining equipment given the difficulty index). What does that mean? If miners need to cover their costs, they need to sell the BTC at market prices to pay the bills. If now they are only keeping 10% or less, then itâs another 22.5 coins on average hitting the exchanges every 10 minutes vs 12.5 coins in a 50% margin scenario (in actuality, the pools pay out on different timescales, but this is an approximation and oversimplification in order to make the point).
I agree with pretty much all of Vinnyâs main points. I have been on record saying the recent surge and plunge is eerily similar to the 2013 surge and plunge. If that pattern repeats, we should see the next big move this summer. Vinny thinks the price may flatline for longer than that before moving strongly again.
On the other hand, there has been a lot positive news as well. We have seen some of the most brilliant venture capitalists in the world continue to put a great deal of time and money into crypto-currency related enterprises, as well as continued merchant adoption, with the biggest news being Overstock.
As Bitcoin stabilizes below $500 for the first time since itâs eye-popping run to over $1,000 in November 2013, many crypto pundits are scratching their heads and trying to make sense of the current weaknessâââespecially given the excitement & innovation that we are seeing within the global Bitcoin community. Venture capital has also been pouring into Bitcoin startups at a rabid pace (north of $100m so far this past year). However, over the past couple of days, Iâve had numerous friends contact me asking the same question : âWhatâs happening with Bitcoin?â.
Finding Equilibrium: Searching for the true value of a Bitcoin. by Vinny Lingham
The upside of the IRS guidance is that given itâs not classified of a currency, you can buy and hold Bitcoin for years and never pay taxes until you realize the gain. Contrast that against the treatment of foreign currency holdings (and subsequent appreciation against the USD) and youâll see itâs a fair outcome.
In the not too distant future, entrepreneurs & technologists will use the actual Bitcoins themselves in new and interesting ways (think smart contracts, etc.) âhow many will be ultimately needed is unknown, and thatâs what creates the imbalance in price. Right now itâs all speculation as to what that future value of a Bitcoin will equate to. This is what makes the Blockchain far more interesting than the actual Bitcoinâââbut Iâll leave that for a future post.
Consumers are spooked right now. MtGox ran away with $500m+ in Bitcoins and is bankrupt. No one really trusts any of the exchangesâââeven some smaller exchanges went under the past 3 months. The only âsafeâ place to buy Bitcoin in the USA is via Coinbase and they are not an exchange.
Itâs been a wild 2014 so far for Bitcoin. On the one hand, there has been some very bad news in the space. Weâve had the Mt. Gox disaster and the potential overhang those stolen coins have on the market, as well as rumors of an effective Chinese ban (we still donât have confirmation of anything).
Anyone who made 5000%+ returns over the past year or so should not be complaining about paying capital gains taxâââit could have been worse and been classified as income tax. That said, it will have an impact on the price of Bitcoin as some people holding them will need to sell some of their coins ahead of tax filing next month.
TechCrunch published aÂ storyÂ yesterday about the recent IRS rulings around Bitcoinâââwhich classifies it as an asset, not a currency (which effectively makes transactions using it taxable). To be frank, anyone who thought that Bitcoin would not be subject to taxes in some form is living in a dream world.
I spent some time at theÂ CoinSummitÂ conference in San Francisco last week and my panel discussion, âBitcoin transactionsâââwhat are the barriers for merchant and consumer adoption?â was well received by the community.
Again, a lack of buyers will leave Bitcoin with a lower settling price and equilibrium point in the broader market.
In reality, anyone who buys Bitcoin with the view that it can only go up and up forever is most likely a speculative and uninformed buyer who will sell at the first sign of blood. Although every new technology will have these buyers, the recent dip in prices is likely to keep these types away and as a result, less speculative buying which will allow Bitcoin time to find equilibrium, before it runs again (historically Bitcoin goes through spikes and consolidation phases regularly).
Its very clear that Bitcoin has amazing potential but the fact remains that we are still in the very early stages of itâs evolutionâââwhich many have likened to the Internet in 1993. Mainstream consumer adoption is just not there yet. Weâre waiting for the âNetscape momentâ for Bitcoin.
If you were a miner 2-5 years ago, you could comfortably mine Bitcoins and make profit margins of 50-95%. Input costs would have been electricity and additional hardware. The difficulty of mining was low and it was not very competitive, so labor costs were cheap (hobbyists mainly) and you didnât have to invest in chip R&D.. Since then, weâve seen a surge in competition amongst miners and an astronomical increase in the difficulty index (far outpacing the price growth in the actual Bitcoin).
This is a key issue that is creating sell side pressure for Bitcoin. The number of new merchants now accepting Bitcoin globally has grown in the region of 5-10 times in the past six months, especially since Bitcoin popped late last year and become an increasingly valuable (albeit volatile) asset to own. The number of consumers (and realistically, mainstream consumers) using Bitcoin has grown fractionally in the same periodâââpartially due to the perceived price and some other issues which Iâll dive into below. One reason is that the promise of micropayments for Bitcoin has not been realized, which is what is holding back mainstream adoption.
I have some alternative views (i.e. not stuff the mainstream press totally gets), as to why Bitcoin is trading below $500 right now, but I want to point out that I am a Bitcoin bull for the long term. I evenÂ predictedÂ at the Silicon Valley Bitcoin Conference in May 2013, it would reach over $1,000 in 2013 when it was trading at $100 to audible sniggers and laughs from a very Bitcoin friendly audience.
In Liberty, Michael Krieger
Zedd, 3LAU and Big Sean: Tickets On Sale for First Blockchain Music Festival
Tickets for the first music festival set to be powered by blockchain technology are now on sale.
Scheduled for this fall, the Our Music Festival is launching its own virtual currency — the OMF toke
How Crypto Reacted to This Week's SEC Bitcoin ETF Delay
It was an expected result at an unexpected time.
The news broke on August 7 that the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is kicking the can on its decision to approve or disapprove a prop
Microsoft Looks to Trusted Computing for Blockchain Security Boost
Two newly published patent applications from Microsoft suggest that the software giant is looking at the use of trusted execution environments, or TEEs, within its blockchain offerings.
Crypto Millionaire Lost 5,500 Bitcoins in Alleged Investment Scam
A 22-year-old cryptocurrency millionaire has lost more than 5,500 bitcoins in an alleged investment scam in Thailand – one that drew public attention due to the involvement of a local actor.
China's Communist Party Publishes Blockchain Tech 101
China's Communist Party is moving to make blockchain literacy the norm across public offices with the publication of an explainer for officials and members.
Released by the publishing house of the
Blockchain Social Network Minds Is Migrating to Ethereum for Launch
Blockchain-based social network Minds is migrating its platform to the ethereum network, the startup announced Monday.
After roughly four-and-a-half months on its Rinkeby test network, the startup
Bitcoin Trading Is Illegal in Saudi Arabia, Warn Watchdogs
A governmental committee comprised of Saudi Arabian regulators has issued a statement clarifying that cryptocurrency trading is illegal in the kingdom.
According to a statement issued Sunday, the s
Former S&P President Leads Seed Round for ICO Compliance Startup
Regtech and compliance startup iComply has just completed a seed funding round led by former Standard and Poor's president Deven Sharma.
The firm – which seeks to develop standard compliance tools