Bitcoin’s price remained stable as news surfaced of a bug in Bitcoin Unlimited (BU) shutting down half of its nodes.
On Tuesday, BU’s node numbers dropped suddenly from around 800 to 400, with developer Andrew Stone and investor Roger Ver subsequently confirming that an attacker exploited a bug in the protocol.
Stone wrote on Tuesday:
“We are seeing an abnormal, hard-to-create input result in a negative outcome so we are classifying this as a network attack.”
The events unleashed a frenzy of social media activity which even engulfed some of cryptocurrency’s best-known names.
Core developer Peter Todd took to Twitter to deny any involvement in the bug, about which he tweeted an hour after the malicious episode began.
FYI, BU nodes started crashing about 30 mins after BU published it on Github; I tweeted 1hr later. I had _nothing_ to do with the attack. pic.twitter.com/C0WWMG80ab
Responding to Todd, tech blogger Avatar X alleged that fellow developer Greg Maxwell had said that two further bugs were present in BU which had “yet to be fixed.”
Ver, meanwhile, received hostility. One BU node operator accused him and other responsible parties of “plain incompetence” as panic gripped a community to whom Ver had only last week unveiled a brand new mining pool.
"Normally, in Bitcoin Unlimited when we find a Core bug we just fix it and move on" https://t.co/cqQaIm5FZJ
Litecoin creator Charlie Lee added to the criticism of BU, stating that the bug “proves that users cannot trust Bitcoin’s $20B network in the hands of BU developers.”
1/ Today’s Bitcoin Unlimited node crashing bug proves that users cannot trust Bitcoin’s $20B network in the hands of BU developers.
Lee also quoted suspicions that Stone’s description of BU “vulnerability” did not mathematically add up.
Disappointed to see doctored image (left) in @GAndrewStone's post about a BU vulnerability. Doesn't even sum to 100% https://t.co/Byirt7eiCL pic.twitter.com/EArZwFSyOb
Only Andreas Antonopoulos, commentating that “individual incompetence” was not the root cause of the problem, appeared to remain neutral on Wednesday.
“It's about a process with diverse and laborious review, which catches bugs before production,” he continued in a series of tweets, while nonetheless praising Bitcoin Core’s development structure.
“Blaming this on "incompetence" of BU devs misses the point & undervalues the invisible but highly effective QA process that Core offers.”
BU bug: This isn't about individual competence. It's about a process with diverse and laborious review, which catches bugs before production
Malta Gets Its First Bitcoin ATM, Unveils Blockchain Plans
Malta has received its first bitcoin ATM as the Maltese government unveils plans to make it the first country to embrace the blockchain.
According to a report from the Malta Chamber, the bitcoin AT
Bitcoin Price Recovers Past $2,500; Is $5,000 In Sight?
The bitcoin price recovered past $2,500 on Thursday, leading the markets to a moderate recovery after yesterday’s decline. Thirteen of the top 15 coins experienced price increases, and three of them s
True Flip Enters into a Strategic Partnership with DAO.Casino to Extend its Gaming Options
In a bid to improve user experience, True Flip has announced strategic partnership with DAO.Casino. True Flip, the provably fair international blockchain lottery, and DAO.Casino, the decentralized
Indian State Officials to Weigh Policies for Public Sector Blockchain Use
Officials in the Indian state of Karnataka are planning an event on blockchain and governance in the near future – a step that could ultimately lead to new regulations in the tech-oriented region.
Malta Intends to Legalize Use of Cryptocurrencies at Online Casinos
The government of Malta is advancing its plans to allow the legal use of digital currencies such as Bitcoin at online casinos. The Malta Gaming Authority (MGA), which supervises both land-based
HitBTC Confirms Bitcoin Cash Futures Trading, Will Credit User Accounts
HitBTC has joined the exchanges announcing its official stance towards the controversial new Bitcoin fork Bitcoin Cash (BCC). In comments to Cointelegraph before an official statement to users,
SEC ICO Guideline Will Affect Blockchain: Cornell University Professor
Cornell University Professor Emin Gun Sirer said that ICO guidelines issued by the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in late July 2017 will have a “chilling effect” on Blockchain technology
A New SegWit Lock-In Period Has Started and All Mining Pools Are Signaling
A new signaling period for the long-debated code change Segregated Witness (SegWit) just started — and it looks like it might be the last.
If at least 95% of blocks during the 2,016-block period si