Currently, India faces devastating cash problems, unique and unprecedented especially for a country of its size. Governments of countries with highly developed financial systems too have proposed to scrape bank notes or at least decommission the highest denominations.
In India, the government announced overnight their two largest denominations, worth roughly US$15 and 7.5 respectively, would cease to be legal tender immediately.
Citizens had about one month to convert their cash reserves into new notes, with many problems being reported around the availability of notes and long queues at the bank tellers.
As Bloomberg points out, less than 10% of all Indians have ever used another payment method other than cash, and only two percent have ever used a mobile phone to pay for something.
Other countries too consider stepping in India’s footsteps. There is a debate in Australia over whether the AU$100 note should be withdrawn from circulation, the European Central Bank has already made the decision to phase out the EUR500 bill, and in the United States Professor Kenneth Rogoff of Harvard University has made a name for himself by campaigning for the abolishing of cash altogether.
The arguments are always similar. Cash enables illicit transactions such as drug trade or illegal prostitution, its anonymous nature encourages tax evasion and bribery, and ever since we have entered the epoch of negative interest, there is concern that too much cash usage reduces the effects of central bank policy.
Blockchain, the technology underpinning cryptographic tokens such as Bitcoin and Ethereum, has increasingly caught the eyes of central banks. China, for example, is rumoured to be building its own virtual currency on top of a blockchain-like system.
When central banks, or any banks for that matter, speak about Blockchain, they often do not refer to systems that work exactly like Bitcoin does. It is hard to imagine how a bank would favor building a system that they, in the long run, have no control over, and which they would not be able to derive profits from.
Private, permissioned blockchains are intended to keep serving the interests of the banks and governments, and will in effect function similarly to existing systems, requiring identification, being subject to seizure and monitoring.
Cash is not only popular because of its use as a private and discrete mechanism to transfer value. Its reach goes far beyond that of money laundering, drugs, and bribery.
Most importantly, cash can be received by anybody. An undocumented immigrant can receive cash in the same way as a small child, a machine, a felon or someone who recently declared insolvency.
Additionally, cash payments are highly reliable. While it may not be trivial to validate their authenticity, a cash payment never fails due to electricity outages, account irregularities or software glitches. Cash never gets stuck in the system, requiring “additional documentation” or repeated trips to the bank to unfreeze the payment.
Banning cash and replacing it with a private blockchain or government issued e-currency does not remove the demand for cash, nor will it be able to replace it.
Without making onboarding trivial and allowing those without legal documentation to safely and reliably bank on the new systems, the removal of cash from an economy removes certain activities in the short run, which is undesired in case these activities are legal. For many people, it is equivalent to a loss of their job.
In the long run, their prospects, and with them the prospects of the black market, depend on whether they can move their transactions into a space that functions quite like cash.
We might see the return of gold coins in commerce, or the rise of cryptocurrencies and their public, permissionless blockchains. Barter, too, can for a short time offer relief from unavailability of cash.
The demand for cash in an economy can be fulfilled by other mediums of exchange that a government has a hard time cracking down on. A move away from cash does not necessarily eliminate the undesired activities associated with it. Instead, gold, foreign currency and cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin are ready to fill the void.
Author: David Lang is Communications Manager at ExpressVPN, a Bitcoin accepting VPN provider. Images from Shutterstock.
An Interview With Angelo Melis, Founder of Local World Forwarders (LWF) Project
The applications of blockchain technology across industries is increasing every day. Among these, the supply chain and logistics sector is one among them. Recognizing the need for a complete overhaul
Mario Draghi States There’s no Need for Bitcoin Regulation in Europe Right now
Europe is a rather controversial region when it comes to Bitcoin and cryptocurrencies. Up until this point, there is no hint of any regulatory measures whatsoever. That isnât necessarily a bad
Bitcoin Price Could Reach $10,000 if China Resumes Cryptocurrency Trading This Year
Earlier today, on October 21, the Bitcoin price achieved a new all-time high at $6,199. The market is confident that the price of Bitcoin could reach $10,000 in the mid-term if major markets such as
Coinbase Claims the Bitcoin Gold “Fork” has Already Taken Place
There are some conflicting reports regarding the Bitcoin Gold fork date. This is not entirely surprising, as the project is poorly organized at best. The website claims the âforkâ â which isnâ
Blockchain Asset Fund: Community Driven Investment Solution, Announces BAF Token Fundraiser
The cryptocurrency industry has in the recent days, broken all the past records. The rapid growth in value of the overall market has evoked mixed reactions, with some hailing the digital currency
SegWit2x Lead Mike Belshe: ‘Things Are Looking Good’ for Bitcoin Hard Fork
BitGo chief executive and SegWit2x project lead Mike Belshe says that, despite contention within the bitcoin community related to the block size debate, “things are looking good” for the SegWit2x hard
ECB Chief: Bitcoin Not ‘Mature’ Enough for Regulation
European Central Bank (ECB) chief Mario Draghi says that bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are not mature enough for regulation.
As reported by CNBC, the ECB president made these comments during a
Bitcoin Price Climbs to $6,200 as Record-Setting Advance Continues
Bitcoin’s record-setting run continued on Saturday, as the bitcoin price touched the $6,200 mark to set a new all-time high.
On Friday, bitcoin shocked analysts and investors alike when it made a s