Despite escalating fears that bitcoin could soon undergo a long and messy software upgrade, a developer group at the center of the debate took steps today to allay fears that such an event would be disruptive to the market.
In statements to CoinDesk, the Bitcoin Unlimited software development team, one of several groups seeking to introduce alternative software to the network, said today that it is encouraging bitcoin exchanges to list whichever blockchain is backed by most proof of work as 'BTC', the common designation for bitcoin.
"We at Bitcoin Unlimited are promoting ... improvements to bitcoin's anti-fragility qualities through further decentralization. One aspect of this is removing central planning from block size economics," the statement reads.
"In the unlikely case of a blockchain split, we are not terribly concerned what exchanges decide to list the two tickers as in terms of name, however we strongly advise that exchanges observe Nakamoto Consensus: the chain with most proof-of-work IS the bitcoin currency unit (currently known as BTC or XBT). We are encouraged that exchanges are well prepared for the event of a blockchain split and that this will result in the market deciding which bitcoin will be the most useful and thus valuable in the long term."
The statements follow a decision by nearly 20 bitcoin exchanges last week to clarify how they would handle listings in the event new software was introduced that created two competing bitcoin assets trading on two divergent blockchains (or versions of its transaction history).
The exchanges indicated at the time that they could not "wait for a winner to emerge" given the pressures of a 24-hour market.
In their statement, the companies, which provide buy and sell functionality for bitcoin, indicated they would designate the software versions powered by Bitcoin Core as 'BTC' even if Bitcoin Unlimited had garnered more hashing power from miners (the entities that add transactions to the network and enforce transaction history).
While exchanges said the statement was meant to position the industry sector as one that is open to a free-market decision on how to define bitcoin, it is not been seen by all as neutral.
At issue in the escalating debate is not only a technical disagreement about how best to increase the software's transaction capacity, but the ideological merits underlying such a decision.
As evidenced by the letter and response, this includes disagreement over who has the authority to enforce any consensus on project parameters (including which project would win designation as 'bitcoin', if any).
Bitcoin Unlimited is arguing that, since miners provide security to the blockchain, these entities should determine the outcome of the decision.
"Bitcoin is defined by the chain of valid transactions with the most proof-of-work," Bitcoin Unlimited developer Peter Rizun said.
Still, others associated with the group suggested that they believe such measures are unlikely. Should most major miners migrate to a new blockchain, wallets, exchanges and users would follow suit, argued bitcoin investor and Bitcoin Unlimited backer Roger Ver.
"The first block that is bigger than 1MB is likely to be a non-event," Ver said.
The comments put Bitcoin Unlimited at odds with statements from members within Bitcoin Core, the software program's long-time developer group.
In recent days, some members of this community have stated their position that it is the so-called 'bitcoin economy', made up of users, exchanges and wallets that add value to a blockchain.
Miners, they contend, were originally envisioned as mere desktop computers and never meant to be actors that forced decision-making or dictate the technology's direction.
As for how miners see the events, that consensus is less clear. In statements, ViaBTC chief executive Haipo Yang told CoinDesk that major miners are still in wait-and-see mode, but that most are now considering alternative softwares.
To date, major mining firms, including Bitmain's Antpool, have expressed a desire to run software that would signal for larger blocks. This has, in turn, put pressure on other China-based miners, as Bitmain remains one of the largest providers of hashing power in an industry that has seen rapid consolidation.
Adding to the drama is that, since launching their campaign, Bitcoin Unlimited has suffered two notable software bugs, prompting discussion on the ability of the software to meet market needs.
Fork image via Shutterstock
Bitcoin ProtocolBitcoin UnlimitedMiningTechnology
GDAX Exchange to Reimburse Traders After Ether Flash Crash
GDAX, the digital asset exchange operated by Coinbase, is moving to issue refunds after a stunning flash crash last week stoked anger amongst affected traders.
Ether prices dramatically plunged to
Bitcoin Shows What Banking Should Be: American Banker
American Banker, a daily trade newspaper that has been covering the financial sector since 1836, recently featured an analytical piece by its editor-in-chief Marc Hochstein entitled “How I missed the
Sharing Economy: Why Blockchain Might Be Next Big Thing for Office Rental
The shared workspace model is poised to transform the world of work, catering to current and future trends by creating flexible and adaptive office ecosystems. According to Jones Lang LaSalle, shared
Portugal Wants to Tax Bitcoin Users, despite Lack of Regulations
Just like in the rest of the world, the media in Portugal have been all over bitcoin because of the cryptocurrency’s growing popularity… and value. Back in April, Portuguese newspaper Jornal de Negóci
Cryptocurrency Market: Is There a Price Drop around the Corner?
The cryptocurrency price rally may soon hit a temporary hurdle, leading to a slight fall, before picking up the pace again. The forecast was made by Fred Wilson, a cryptocurrency investor, and
Proof-of-Life: Vitalik Buterin Uses Ethereum to Disprove Death Hoax
Vitalik Buterin, the creator of ethereum, used the technology in an unusual way this weekend, turning to the blockchain network itself to disprove his own death.
The hoax originated on the 4chan in
Major Chinese Bitcoin Exchange Lists Ethereum Classic Ahead of Ethereum
BTCC, the second largest Bitcoin exchange in China and the world, has announced the integration of Ethereum Classic on its newly released digital cryptocurrency exchange BTCC DAX. High-profile
Monday Massacre: Bitcoin, Ethereum Lead the Way as Cryptocurrencies Retreat into the Red
Cryptocurrency traders woke up to a sea of red this morning, as 92 of the top 100 cryptocurrencies by market cap experienced a marked price decline. The bitcoin price led the retreat, falling over 6%