A Chinese cryptocurrency trader who was sent bitcoin in error must repay an exchange even if it broke domestic rules, a Beijing court has ruled.
The case reportedly stemmed from a system bug on a China-based bitcoin exchange named Coinnice, which mistakenly sent five bitcoins to Li on March 10, 2017.
Based on the court document, Li subsequently liquidated the bitcoins for around $6,100. After Li declined Coinnice's request that he return the funds, the company brought a lawsuit against him in a Beijing district court.
During the case, Coinnice argued that Li had no legal right to possession of the assets and, as such, should return the proceeds to the exchange.
The plaintiff further presented the bitcoin address that was assigned to Li on the exchange, proving the transactions to the court. The judge consequently ruled in favor of the plaintiffs in March 2018, saying that by signing up on Coinnice, Li agreed by default to the contractual terms listed on the platform.
However, Li later appealed to the intermediate court making the counter-argument that Coinnice was based in China and should have been be regarded as an illegal operation to begin with, since the People's Bank of China has explicitly prohibited bitcoin trading platforms from providing services to domestic investors.
However, the judge in the appeal ruled that, based on China's civil law, anyone that has made profits without a legal ground and resulted in other people's loss must return the unauthorized assets.
The court went to explain:
"In this case, whether or not Coinnice's establishment as a bitcoin trading platform has violated relevant rules, does not have any impact on Li's liability to return the profits he received with no legal basis. ... As such, the court denies his appeal and the decision is final."
Although codified statutes predominate in China's civil law system, the judgement may still offer a window into the thinking of courts in the country when dealing with disputes involving cryptocurrencies.
In a similar case, crypto exchange OKEx is also facing a lawsuit in which a bitcoin trader is claiming for 38 bitcoin cash that he did not receive after the cryptocurrency's hard fork from bitcoin in August 2017. The divergence meant that anyone with bitcoins at the time would, in theory, also own the new bitcoin cash to an equal amount. However, not all exchanges passed the free coins onto customers.
Bitcoin and banknotes image via Shutterstock
The leader in blockchain news, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups.
Analysis: What 2019 Could Bring for Bitcoin
Trading in altcoins was a big part of what made Bitcoin price spike towards the end of 2017. A section of the crypto space argues that while altcoins helped Bitcoin’s market cap swell, they also bro
Bitcoin Cash Going Down as Stellar Warms up
Bitcoin Cash’s market cap has been cut in half since the Nov. 15 hardfork which birthed the Bitcoin ABC and Bitcoin SV chains. Now at a mere $3.5 bln and a unit price of ~$201 as at the time of writ
300k User Data from Chinese Auto Finance Platform Sold For One Bitcoin on Dark Web
It is revealed that 300,000 pieces of user data from a Chinese auto finance platform Jiurong were compromised and priced at one bitcoin on the dark web.
According to the leaked data posted, persona
Heyday of Bitcoin Mining Rigs Business at China’s Huaqiangbei is Over Amid Crypto Market Carnage
Bitcoin price slumped to a 13-month low of about $4,300 on Wednesday, making mining the world’s leading digital currency an unprofitable business. A lot of mall miners, mining rigs dealers and minin
Dialogue with Bitcoin Evangelist in Latin America: RSK Labs CEO Diego on Crypto Industry
Diego Gutierrez is the CEO at Koibanx and president of Bitcoin Argentina NGO. In addition, Diego also serves as the CEO of Rootstock/RSK Labs, a smart contract platform built on top of bitcoin.
China’s Bitcoin Billionaire Zhao Dong : Bitcoin Price to Hit $50,000 in Three Years—Now Is the Time to Buy the Dip
Despite Bitcoin’s latest crash and a real chance that its price will go much lower, Zhao Dong, prominent Chinese OTC trader and founder of Dfund, remains bullish on the the world’s biggest cryptoc
Bitcoin Miners Sold by Kilo in China Amid Cryptocurrency Crash
The leading cryptocurrency bitcoin once fell below $4,300 on the afternoon of November 20 – down more than 17% on a 24-hour basis and hitting a 13-month low since October 2017. Great losses are seen
Xiao Lei: 3 Main Reasons of the “Unreasonable” Bitcoin Price Crash
Cryptocurrency markets experienced a havoc in the past few days. Bitcoin, the uncrowned king in the crypto world, has fell as much as 30% over the past two weeks, while other major tokens are all suff