A Chinese cryptocurrency trader who was sent bitcoin in error must repay an exchange even if it broke domestic rules, a Beijing court has ruled.
The case reportedly stemmed from a system bug on a China-based bitcoin exchange named Coinnice, which mistakenly sent five bitcoins to Li on March 10, 2017.
Based on the court document, Li subsequently liquidated the bitcoins for around $6,100. After Li declined Coinnice's request that he return the funds, the company brought a lawsuit against him in a Beijing district court.
During the case, Coinnice argued that Li had no legal right to possession of the assets and, as such, should return the proceeds to the exchange.
The plaintiff further presented the bitcoin address that was assigned to Li on the exchange, proving the transactions to the court. The judge consequently ruled in favor of the plaintiffs in March 2018, saying that by signing up on Coinnice, Li agreed by default to the contractual terms listed on the platform.
However, Li later appealed to the intermediate court making the counter-argument that Coinnice was based in China and should have been be regarded as an illegal operation to begin with, since the People's Bank of China has explicitly prohibited bitcoin trading platforms from providing services to domestic investors.
However, the judge in the appeal ruled that, based on China's civil law, anyone that has made profits without a legal ground and resulted in other people's loss must return the unauthorized assets.
The court went to explain:
"In this case, whether or not Coinnice's establishment as a bitcoin trading platform has violated relevant rules, does not have any impact on Li's liability to return the profits he received with no legal basis. ... As such, the court denies his appeal and the decision is final."
Although codified statutes predominate in China's civil law system, the judgement may still offer a window into the thinking of courts in the country when dealing with disputes involving cryptocurrencies.
In a similar case, crypto exchange OKEx is also facing a lawsuit in which a bitcoin trader is claiming for 38 bitcoin cash that he did not receive after the cryptocurrency's hard fork from bitcoin in August 2017. The divergence meant that anyone with bitcoins at the time would, in theory, also own the new bitcoin cash to an equal amount. However, not all exchanges passed the free coins onto customers.
Bitcoin and banknotes image via Shutterstock
The leader in blockchain news, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups.
Bakkt CEO: Crypto Trading Platform Won't Support Margin Trading
Two weeks after the Intercontinental Exchange (ICE) introduced Bakkt, a new digital assets platform, the latter's CEO has set out to explain what the service will offer consumers.
Bakkt chief execu
Blockchain Firm to Raise $24 Billion for Electric Bus Upgrades in China
Blockchain and AI technology company Seven Stars Cloud Group has scored a major deal to help raise $24 billion to fund large-scale electric bus upgrades for China's biggest full-service operator.
SEC Faces Thursday Deadline for ProShares Bitcoin ETF Decision
Less than a month after delaying a decision on a bitcoin-based exchange-traded fund (ETF), the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is poised to approve or disapprove another pair of proposed
Blockchain Enters 'Trough of Disillusionment' on Gartner's Hype Scale
Interest in blockchain technology is waning, research firm Gartner said in its latest "Hype Cycle for Emerging Technologies" report.
Gartner included blockchain, along with four other emerging tech
District Judge Forms Blockchain Law Study Group in South Korea
A group of judges, lawmakers and industry experts in South Korea are forming a new group aimed to discuss legal issues surrounding blockchain technology.
Called the Blockchain Law Society, the grou
SBI Holdings Again Invests in Crypto Exchange Under Scrutiny
SBI Holdings, the investment arm of Japanese financial giant SBI Group, is making a new round of investment in a cryptocurrency exchange that's under increased scrutiny from the country's financial re
21-Year-Old Trader Prosecuted Over Bitcoin Money Laundering
A 21-year-old bitcoin dealer from California is being prosecuted for allegedly committing numerous counts of illegal money transmission and money laundering.
According to an announcement from the D
Police Arrest Hackers Suspected of Stealing $87 Million in Crypto
Chinese police from multiple cities have arrested three individuals who allegedly stole bitcoins and other cryptocurrencies worth around $87 million.
Chinese news agency Xinhua reported on Saturday