A number of well-known crypto startups had their eyes on BitTorrent prior to its acquisition by Tron's Justin Sun.
CoinDesk has learned that in addition to Tron and Neo, blockchain governance-focused project Icon and Protocol Labs, the developers of Filecoin, also entered into talks with BitTorrent to explore a purchase.
People familiar with the negotiations say there were two more parties – both in the blockchain space – that were interested in the peer-to-peer file-sharing company. Sources have not indicated that any companies or persons that were not in the blockchain space showed interest.
Justin Sun, the creator of Tron, ultimately prevailed in acquiring BitTorrent, as Variety first reported in June.
BitTorrent's software in many ways paved the way for today's efforts toward a decentralized internet, but even still the company had historically struggled to create a profitable business. In late 2017, the company lost its founder and the inventor of its most important technologies, Bram Cohen, who went on to found Chia, with the hopes of developing a more eco-friendly crypto mining process.
According to internal documents obtained by CoinDesk, BitTorrent initiated acquisition negotiations when Tron's founder approached BitTorrent's main shareholder, venture capital firm DCM. Specifically, Justin Sun approached David Chao, a BitTorrent board member who controlled the majority of the company's stock, and proposed to purchase DCM's preferred stock in order to gain a controlling stake.
However, Chao pressed Sun to also purchase BitTorrent's common stock to ensure that common stockholders would not be left empty-handed.
As previously reported by CoinDesk, the most significant rival to Sun in the deal was Neo Global Capital, the investment vehicle of NEO, a blockchain project that's been called "China's ethereum." Neo Global Capital had floated an offer that was $50 million higher than that of Sun's, but for various reasons, the deal did not move forward.
BitTorrent documents also claim that, in addition to Sun, there were six other parties in negotiations around the acquisition. Three parties made offers while three others walked away.
CoinDesk has learned that BitTorrent also approached Block.one, the creator of the EOS protocol, to see if it was interested in acquiring the company. As previously reported, Block.one raised $4 billion through a year-long initial coin offering (ICO).
When reached for comment, Block.one CEO Brendan Blumer told CoinDesk in an email: "They approached us and solicited the organization, but we were not interested."
Tron has not yet publicly explained why it acquired BitTorrent, though observers have speculated that Sun saw its 100 million users per month as an asset worth having.
However, more information is known about why the other suitors were interested in the acquisition.
Neo Global Capital, for instance, told CoinDesk that it thought BitTorrent could develop a decentralized file storage protocol that could be useful for decentralized applications (dapps) within its blockchain ecosystem.
According to people familiar with the matter, Protocol Labs saw value in BitTorrent's user base, while sources with knowledge of Icon's negotiations said the project was intrigued by the potential to build BitTorrent's software into its blockchain.
Yet neither Protocol Labs nor Icon made BitTorrent an offer, an outcome that sources attributed to concerns regarding copyright infringement issues associated with the protocol, monetization and the actual integration of the technology, and the company's price tag.
Based on CoinDesk's investigation, it's not clear that the other parties involved in negotiations, with the exception of Tron and Neo Global Capital, could be characterized as serious buyers.
BitTorrent and DCM declined a request for comment from CoinDesk. Tron did not reply to a request for comment.
For Ben Lebeau, the crypto lead at Sandwich Video – one of the most sought-after content production companies in Silicon Valley – it's not difficult to understand why BitTorrent was so desirable.
As an important disruptor in content distribution online, BitTorrent's business model and ethos align with that of the cryptocurrency community.
"Peer-to-peer networks have always pushed this idea that the power to share information should be in the hands of the individual," Lebeau wrote CoinDesk, adding:
"I think you'd be hard-pressed to find anyone who would doubt the impact that BitTorrent had on file sharing before decent content delivery networks and other centralized alternatives existed."
He also acknowledged the view that acquiring the firm was a way for Tron to establish a presence in the U.S. – a theory other observers have put forth.
"On the other hand, it's an exceptionally clever way to migrate more people into the decentralized ecosystem," Lebeau continued, before concluding:
"If Tron can figure out a way to leverage this network, that could move us closer towards creating a true internet of value."
Darts on a dartboard image via Shutterstock
The leader in blockchain news, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups.
BitTorrentEOSBlock.oneFilecoinProtocol LabsJustin SuniconTronDCM
Crypto Firms to Congress: We Need Clarity on Blockchain Token Rules
Some 80 representatives from the cryptocurrency and traditional finance industries trekked to Washington, D.C. on Tuesday with a singular message for U.S. lawmakers: we need regulatory clarity on cryp
Japan Regulators Seek Answers in Wake of Zaif's $60 Million Crypto Hack
Japan's top financial regulator is seeking answers from the operator of the Zaif cryptocurrency exchange, a situation that comes days after the trading site disclosed that it lost millions of dollars
Google to Allow Ads for 'Regulated' Crypto Exchanges Next Month
Search engine giant Google has revealed that it will begin allowing cryptocurrency exchange advertisements in the U.S. and Japan, starting in October.
In a new update to its advertising policies, G
Bitcoin Takes a Step Toward Becoming a 'Multi-Network' Cryptocurrency
A proposal to radically expand the capabilities of bitcoin such that it would be able to add vast new features to its limited supply of cryptocurrency has arrived on testnet.
Paul Sztorc, director
Music-Sharing Startup Audius Gives New Details on Twin Crypto Tokens
Soon after closing a $5.5 million funding round, music-focused blockchain startup Audius is revealing just how its network will operate when it launches in roughly a year.
As previously reported, t
Mt Gox Trustee Has Sold $230 Million in Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash Since March
The trustee for the now-defunct cryptocurrency exchange Mt. Gox has revealed new details about the pace of cryptocurrency sales as part of the firm's bankruptcy and rehabilitation process.
Bearish Cross Hints at More Losses Ahead for Bitcoin Price
Bitcoin (BTC) is on the defensive, having breached crucial support on Monday and could suffer a deeper drop, courtesy of a bearish crossover between key moving averages.
As of writing, BTC is chang
Over 75 New Banks: JPMorgan Expands Blockchain Payments Trial
A major blockchain payments trial launched by JPMorgan, Australia's ANZ and the Royal Bank of Canada has just gained over 75 new banks as participants.
As reported by CoinDesk, the three banks set